A short time ago Google released their own web based RSS reader. I decided to check it out today to see if was any good. One thing to note is that it’s still a “beta” product and like most tools from Google it is free.
To access the Google Reader you will need a Google account, if you don’t have one you can create one on the same page. Before you continue reading I must confess that I hate web-based applications… so there is my disclaimer! These are my findings:
It took me a while to get used to the interface and it was confusing at first. The web page is split into three sections:
A. The top bar where you have the following options: Home, Read items, Starred, Subscriptions and Labels. This is where I got confused because I am used to the top bar of a web page being a navigation menu taking me to different pages on a site. The first three items (home, read and starred) are actually filters on your news items and the last three items are “management” items.
B. The next section is the left pane that displays your list of news items. A box surrounds the current news item and the item is shown on the right pane. A list of “controls” (top, up, down, refresh and page up) is located at the top of the pane for you to move through the items. At the bottom of the left pane you can sort items by date or automatically. There is also an additional filter there where you can select whether to display or hide your read items. Next to each list item is a small star that you click on to star/unstar the news item.
C. The right hand pane displays your selected news item. There are also additional options here to unsubscribe from the RSS feed, email the item and blog about it (if you have a blogger account).
So what do I think of Google’s reader? I don’t like it and I definitely won’t be using it anytime soon. The interface is semi-confusing and news item control is spread all over the place.
A few of the things that I don’t like:
- You have two different places on the screen to apply filtering on your items - the top pane to select all, read or starred items and then the left pane to hide or display read items.
- If I want to star an item I need to go to the left pane, to keep an item unread I have to go to the right pane.
- When I subscribe to a feed I want to get a complete list of items from that feed. I don’t want to click a link saying “To return more items from source…” to get all the news items.
- I like to have a list of subscriptions “on hand” so that when I select one I only get it’s new items.
On the plus side of the equation these are the two things that I like:
- I can sort my news items by date
- I have a direct link to Blogger to blog about a news item.
Selection of an RSS reader is a matter of personal choice and preference. If you use Google Reader and like it feel free to comment below or, if you agree with me, share what you don’t like about Google Reader.
Technorati Tags: RSS Readers